circularity
Word family
Synonym discussion
Sense: noun/1
All four terms describe reasoning that turns back on itself, but they differ in scope and register. Circularity is the broadest term: it covers any argument where the conclusion is secretly assumed in the premise, making the reasoning invalid without requiring outside evidence. Tautology is a narrower, stricter type of circularity — a statement that is true by definition and therefore conveys no new information (e.g. 'All bachelors are unmarried men'). Vicious circle (or vicious cycle) shifts the focus from logic to real-world situations: a problem that creates another problem, which then makes the original problem worse (e.g. poverty leading to poor education leading to poverty). Self-reference is a neutral structural feature — a statement that refers to itself — and is not inherently a flaw: 'This sentence contains five words' is self-referential but perfectly meaningful. In academic writing, circularity is the preferred term for critiquing a theory or argument, while tautology is used for statements that are empty by definition.
Common collocations
Nouns
- logical circularity
- circularity error
- circularity argument
Phrases
- a circularity of reasoning
- a degree of circularity
Prepositions
- circularity in (an argument, reasoning)
- circularity of (an object)
Etymology
From Latin 'circularis' (round, like a circle) combined with the English suffix '-ity' (forming nouns that mean 'quality or state of'). The geometric sense — describing how round something is — appeared in the 1500s. The logical sense developed in the 1600s, as writers began using the image of a circle to describe arguments that 'go round in a circle' and never reach a real conclusion.